General development issues discussed by the BANG committee

Click here to see latest Area Panel information

October 2005

The BANG committee was informed of changes in the definition and regulation of Houses in Multiple Occupancy (HMOs).

University accommodation - Student village developments

Phase 1 is expected to begin in early 2006 with construction of the Hub and new accommodation on the Wolfson Flats site, Stephenson Hall tennis courts and at Earnshaw, together with refurbishment of Crewe Hall. Phase 2 will see completion of the remaining new build and refurbishment of Stephenson Hall. Phases 1 & 2 will take two & half years approx. Phase 3 will see the development of Ranmoor House.

September 2005

University accommodation

BANG has written to the City Council objecting to the development of the Tapton Hall site as proposed, particularly in respect of the small number of family houses planned, inadequate parking provision, the density of the development, and the potential traffic volumes. 

July 2005

University accommodation - Student village developments

The University has set up a Construction Interface Group, with representation of BANG.

From The Banger
April 2005

Public Meeting at 7.30 pm on 13 April about
the University’s revised “Student Village” plans
in Heeley Memorial Hall Birkdale School (Endcliffe Crescent entrance)

Dear Neighbour

Sheffield University has re-submitted its planning applications to develop a “Student Village” on the Endcliffe and Ranmoor sites and for linked developments on Westbourne Road (below the former Radio Sheffield building) and on the tennis courts at Stephenson Hall on Oakholme Road. The applications are likely be considered by the City Council in April or May.

The “Student Village” and associated developments have long-term implications for the character of Broomhill, Endcliffe and Ranmoor. That is why BANG (Broomhill Action and Neighbourhood Group) has joined with REACT (Riverdale and Endcliffe Action Group) to organise a Public Meeting for local residents to hear about and see more of the new plans and to voice their opinions.

We have also invited local Councillors, including members of the West Planning Board, our MP and the prospective parliamentary candidates, representatives from the University and the local media. HOWEVER, the main purpose of the meeting is to give you an opportunity to have your say. Make a note in your diary and please make every effort to attend.

BANG Committee

 

The BANGER’s perspective

It’s no exaggeration to say that many in the neighbourhood feel profoundly shocked by the University’s proposals. The Endcliffe site and the surrounding roads and buildings is one of the finest suburban settings in the UK, meriting proposals with vision and architecture of landmark quality. The University could go to the best in the architectural community – as it has done in the past and as leading universities continue to do – seeking imaginative ideas for using the site and the highest architectural talent. It could do this in consultation with the surrounding communities, tapping into the  reservoir of goodwill and readiness to help which is there for the asking. And it could enhance S10, and the whole City of Sheffield, as a place to visit, live, study and work. The University hasn’t done this, yet: there is still time for it to change its approach from “what can we get away with?” to “how can we do all of us proud?”

At the moment, the University is proposing to increase by more than 40% the number of students on its Endcliffe, Ranmoor, Westbourne Road and Oakholme Road/Ashdell Road sites. This will push the student population of Broomhill towards, perhaps beyond, 50% (it was 40% in the 2001 census), inevitably making worse the noise, litter and random damage experienced by local residents. To house these students it proposes system-built structures with “cosmetic” treatment to roofs and elevations where they adjoin the traditional buildings of the conservation areas, buildings which reflect the PFI-style basis of the development in which a contractor (Bovis Lendlease, it is now reported) will build everything and maintain it for 40 years in return for students’ rents.

Please come to the meeting on 13 April and please comment on the planning applications to the City Council (details overleaf).

Letters on the University’s Planning Applications, quoting the references
04/04058/FUL, 04/04108/LBC and 04/04084/CAC
should be sent to:

Trevor Sullivan
Assistant Principal Planning Officer
Development Environment and Leisure
Sheffield City Council
Howden House
1 Union Street
Sheffield S1 2SH

Although public notices stipulate that written comments should be submitted by 30 March 2005, we have been assured that late submissions will be accepted.

September 2004

University accommodation - disposal and new developments

In March 2004 the University announced its intention to dispose of around 140 of its residential properties. Then in July it announced the sale of further properties: in Ruth Square, Glossop Road, Broomspring Lane and Dorset Street. University properties in the Tapton district, comprising Tapton Hall of Residence, buildings used by the University's Music Department, and botanical research facilities are also to be put up for sale. Also on disposal list is 31-53 Taptonville Road, a complex of 60 bedrooms.
The University of Sheffield Student Residences Strategy also centres on the disposal and re-provision of much of the accommodation in the Endcliffe and Ranmoor areas, to create a purpose-built, state-of-the-art community for 5,000 students. This development will involve the demolition of some accommodation, including Sorby Hall, and the construction of new facilities, built round a central building to the south of The Paddock in Endcliffe Crescent, which will be preserved and enhanced in the scheme. This central building will include a full range of catering, retail, recreational and welfare facilities. This will be a massive development! Needless to say the University gives assurances that there will be a period of public consultation on the Master Plan proposals to be unveiled at a public exhibition, before a planning application is submitted to Sheffield City Council. In the meantime interested parties are invited to contact Andrew Henderson on 07968 559 076 or Sam Hinton-Smith on 07968 558 623.

Other developments Two planning applications have been submitted concerning Westbourne House at 17-21 Westbourne Road. The first is for 17 apartments in the original old house. The second is for the erection of five two bed- roomed apartments with associated car parking. Strangely enough parking is not mentioned in connection with the seventeen apartments, but putting the two applications together you get the need for an awful lot of parking spaces. Where are all the cars going to go in this crowded part of Broomhill? What will happen to traffic when the Westbourne Road Project with its one-way system starts?

Telecommunications

Two applications affecting Fulwood and Lodge Moor are to be investigated by a government inspector after being rejected by the City Council. As for the telecommunication mast for the top of Pegasus House at the corner of Glossop Road and Westbourne Road, the city council planning officers concluded that the equipment on top of this six-storey office block would not be unduly prominent from long distances‚ and would not harm the appearance of the Broomhill Conservation Area! Seven letters, including one from BANG were received, raising issues such as the impact on the skyline and the proximity to houses and schools. The council says it has to follow national policy that any health implications are a matter for central government not the local planning system. At the meeting on16 August councillors were told that the application was being withdrawn to allow for wider consultation. Local residents will in the meantime have seen a massive crane at work hoisting something on to the roof of Pegasus House. Despite what the planning officers think this ugly building in this part of the Broomhill Conservation Area now looks even uglier.

March 2004

Planning Applications:Prince Naseem comes to Broomhill?

Prince Naseem has won the right to redevelop the site in Northumberland Road of the present British Glass Manufacturers Confederation Headquarters. More flats? InterContinental Hotels Group has taken the decision to sell Holiday Inn Sheffield West. Where are the Fitness Club members going to go? Change of use might mean building flats on this whole site. Watch this space… And what about the Westbourne House Hotel, which is also on the market? What does this all mean?

Some good news for Broomhill/Broomhall

BANG members will be pleased to hear that a couple ofmulti-occupancy applications were turned down despite being recommended for approval by Planning Officers. Oddbins 323 Ecclesall Rd. - Application to increase upstairs area from 4 students to 9 -and Turners Lane - Extension to roof and use of building as 3 flats. Well done Fred Everill of Parkers Rd.!

Student Accommodation Signs Following numerous complaints from Councillors and the public the Head of Planning intends to take legal action against property owners displaying unauthorised signs advertising student accommodation within the South Board Area.

Permanent student accommodation signs and banners etc? Do you have a problem?

Contact the Sheffield City Council Enforcement Office: 2734258.

December 2003

Warning Over Student 'Tension'. This was the headline in the Sheffield Telegraph of 5 December 2003 indicating that Broomhill was once again in the news! The article in the paper was a result of a meeting of the Broomhill Forum at which the matter of Houses in Multiple Occupancy had been raised. One local resident, a wife and mother with young children, broke down in tears at the meeting when she tried to describe what life was like in her street now that most of the houses had been taken oven by developers and packed with students. Following its meeting in the Broomhill Methodist Church, BANG had already decided to assemble statistics street by street about this once creeping but now accelerating plague of HMOs in the streets around the University of Sheffield. According to the Sheffield Telegraph a Sheffield University spokesman said: "We are as keen as anyone to avoid development of so-called 'student ghettos' which have caused long-running tensions in other cities. Student-community relations in Sheffield are as harmonious as in any university city and we want to keep them that way‚". Clearly the unnamed university spokesman needs to talk to the people who actually have to live in the streets around the university of Sheffield, people like the mother who broke down in tears at the Broomhill Forum. There is no problem? All is harmony? Nothing can be done?

You Win Some And You Lose Some - Telecommunications Mast on Pegasus House. According to guidelines The Council has to consider: *Current advice from the Government; *Policies in Sheffield's Unitary Development Plan; and *other planning decisions and appeals. The Council must also protect the amenities of an area, including those of individual occupiers.  Important considerations include whether or not proposed mobile phone developments are unsightly or over-dominate nearby housing.  Protecting high quality or sensitive areas, such as the Green Belt or Listed Buildings, is also important. It seems the Council has decided not to protect the amenities of the Broomhill Conservation Area and is going to allow the mast on Pegasus House. BANG and the local residents have lost this battle. BANG did, however, win another little battle. The Place was refused permission to have an outside drinking area. It went to appeal and lost. No outside drinking there!

Oct 2003

TOWN & GOWN: Throughout August, the Times Higher Education Supplement has run a series of articles on the theme of 'Town & Gown'. This series of articles suggests a sea change in the image of universities. It is being publicly acknowledged that universities are not necessarily an unmixed blessing to their host communities. Now the THES is saying: "While large towns are crying out for universities, seeing the economic benefits that they can confer, some communities in existing university cities are ruing the social impact of an influx of students. Whole areas are being colonised by student landlords, placing property beyond the reach of most families. Those who remain complain of rowdyism and a demographic mix that renders schools unviable. Studentification and Houses in Multiple Occupation (HMO's) will be a topic for BANG's next public meeting on 12 November in the Broomhill Methodist church.  Meanwhile, here in Sheffield, we learn that the University's plan to sell off halls of residence is in doubt following further consideration of the appropriateness of this move.  BANG will make common cause with students on this, as University provision suits both students and permanent residents much better than letting the market determine our fate.

The introduction of PLAN4 Transport in S10 will result in measures to keep all traffic moving better, particularly along the A57 Manchester Road/ Whitham Road/Western Bank (which has been designated as a 'Gold Route' &endash; i.e. a major access route into the city).  For details contact Information Line: 0845 30 30 343 or Website: www.citymatters. co.uk

March 2003

NEW COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENTS IN BROOMHILL:
A new T & A shoe shop has been opened up next to B&B; there have been announcements in the press about a proposed new deli to be called Ma*rx, offering "funky" food and drink. It is currently being fitted out in the premises next door to Wine Rack. The deli will specialise in organic fruit and vegetables from the UK with a large selection of cheeses and cured meats. The espresso bar will only use fair traded coffee. The owner is planning to launch the business around the middle of March. On the same side of the street a Stash Box has opened selling hookahs and other smoking paraphernalia. No admittance for anyone under sixteen!

December 2002

The following item appeared in the Sheffield Star on 4 November:

Residents' meetings with Sheffield High School

Two meetings of the High School and local residents' representatives have taken place. The following were the main points covered:
1. The school's development plans: The school told of its needs to improve facilities for existing pupil numbers rather than to increase numbers. Plans include an additional storey on the existing single-storey science lab close to Melbourne Avenue and an upwards extension of the flat roof of Moor Lodge, the building opposite the main school on Rutland Park. The school is also seeking to acquire a house on Melbourne Avenue (either no 3 or no 4) to improve facilities for the junior school and to establish a day nursery.
Sale of 17-21 Westbourne Road is envisaged, and the caretaker is to move from there to live at 43 Rutland Park.

2. Issues of concern to residents: The need for a list of events that bring increased traffic and parking - dismay at the inconsiderate behaviour of parents in cars.

3. Issues of concern to the school: Unauthorised use of the school grounds as a short cut when the Newbould Lane gate is open for access by gardeners; litter around the school, especially on Newbould Lane.

4. Traffic matters: The school encourages pupils to use the private coaches and public transport, however, many parents are averse to their daughters using public transport. It was agreed to meet jointly with council officers so as to work out mutually acceptable implementation of the forthcoming parking and traffic management schemes.

Next meeting is set for Monday 24th March.

Proposed pedestrian crossing at Botanical Gardens, Clarkehouse Road.
BANG fully supports this proposal as a means of increasing road safety and pedestrian convenience in an area of considerable pedestrian flow. It will directly benefit residents, local school children, students and visitors to the enhanced Botanical Gardens.

September 2002

Plan 4 Transport in S10 Improving Broomhill

The council is now completing the design work on several schemes in the Broomhill area. These include: New pedestrian facilities at the Newbould Lane/Glossop Road junction. A traffic calming and 20 mile mph zone on Taptonville Road, Lawson Road and Sale Hill. Refurbishment of car parks on Spooner Road and Parkers Lane. According to the latest information the Taptonville Road/Lawson Road/Sale Hill scheme is now fully designed. The intention will be to construct this year. As for the Westbourne Road Area Scheme a revised one way system is to be received on 30 September by South Area Board. Local properties will be informed of the revised scheme nearer the time. The Newbould Lane/Glossop Road pedestrian facilities scheme is to be issued to Street Force this month. Design work is underway for all the major Broomhill junctions. Installation of CCTV cameras is in hand.

The first set of highway developments in the PLAN S10 programme is getting under way through a local community information programme on Fulwood Road between Manchester Road and Endcliffe Vale Road. These proposals join up with the road safety scheme being built outside Notre Dame school. Detailed information about these developments can be obtained by calling the information line on 0845 30 30 343. A nine month clampdown by the police on parking at urban clearway times and in bus lanes has just started. With regard to Urban Clearway, Prohibition and Restricting of Waiting and Bus Stop Clearway Orders the Council has announced such Orders. The effect will be to: a) introduce Urban Clearway Restrictions (No Waiting and No Loading/Unloading 0800-0930 & 1630-1830 Monday-Friday) on the whole of that part of Fulwood Road between its junctions with Manchester Road and Ashdell Road; b) introduce a Prohibition of Waiting At Any time on the whole of that part of Fulwood Road between its junctions with Manchester Road and Endcliffe Vale Road; c) designate roads as Bus Stop Clearways At All Times (no stopping except buses within the marked areas at bus stops).

3,000 student flats going up for sale. This was the headline in the Sheffield Telegraph on 9 August 2002. The article went on to say that two halls of residence - Tapton and Ranmoor - are to be sold along with hundreds of flats around Endcliffe, Broomhill and Hunters Bar. Clearly the impact of this change of university policy on Broomhill is potentially enormous. It remains to be seen whether the flats which go on the market in Broomhill are bought by private persons and families or whether they are snapped up by big landlords.

Broomhill residents win battle over flats - Girls school wins fight for building. The Sheffield Telegraph on 2 August 2002 had two stories of interest to Broomhill residents, both concerning planning applications opposed by BANG. Firstly the Telegraph's readers were informed that Broomhill residents had won a battle over flats. This was about a campaign waged by local residents and BANG to prevent a block of flats being built in the grounds of a Victorian villa. Planning permission was unanimously refused for 11 flats in the grounds of 16 Manchester Road, near the junction with Sale Hill. The Local Planning Authority considered that the proposed development would by virtue of its design and location have a detrimental effect on the amenities of the residents of adjoining properties (at Tapton Mount Close, Sale Hill and Manchester Road) by being overbearing for them, by affecting their outlook, by resulting in a loss of light to them and by compromising their privacy. The Local Planning Authority also considered that the proposal by virtue of its design would neither preserve nor enhance the character or appearance of the Broomhill Conservation Area, and that the proposed development would result in the provision of an inadequately designed parking layout which would be detrimental to safe manoeuvring of vehicles on site.

The second Telegraph story concerned a planning application for Change of Use Decision by the The Girls Day School Trust for the use of offices at 4 Melbourne Avenue for educational purposes including a children's nursery. At the planning board meeting the vote went 4-3 in favour of the Sheffield Girls High School's wish to expand into this Victorian property despite strong opposition from local residents already deeply concerned about parking problems in the area. The verdict means that the school can use the building currently occupied by architects HLM for a day nursery for up to 20 children acting as a feeder for the main school and for teaching accommodation for the junior department. The application prompted 22 letters of objection and a protest from BANG.

December 2001

The High School's application for educational use of a large detached house at 16 Rutland Park was refused on 26 November. Residents' complaints at the impact on their amenity of the school's uncooperative management prompted comments from a Councillor that were picked up by the Star, which also reported the head's response to this criticism. A subsequent letter from 22 residents explaining the basis for their complaint and requesting improved neighbourly relations was also printed. These are reproduced here. Residents' comments to the planning board were not directed at other schools in the area. Residents are now actively seeking a meeting with the High School to establish a better relationship.

November 2001

This special edition is to promote the widest possible involvement in the Council's consultation on its parking and traffic management proposals. BANG supports the Councils efforts to improve parking and traffic management in Broomhill and urges all residents to have their say in the Council's consultation by:

- Returning the questionnaire that is going out to households within the area included in the scheme

- Taking part in the open days on 3rd December at the Fulwood Road Methodist Church and 10th December at Hanover Methodist Church, Filey Street, Broomhall, both from 1.00 to 8.00 pm.

For years, the BANG committee has debated members' concerns at the ever-worsening parking and traffic problems of our neighbourhood. Until now, the Council has not come up with any substantial improvements. Other parts of the city have done better, with traffic calming and parking priorities that have significantly improved the amenity and convenience of residents,whilst also protecting local businesses from the worst effects of commuter traffic and parking. We now see the first phase of the Council's programme for Broomhill, to which new energy and resources are being committed alongside continuing consultations with the community.

Consultations during 2000 established local priorities to be:

- Reduced congestion

- Improved pedestrian safety

- Slower traffic speeds

- Reduced through traffic and commuter parking

Although no solution is perfect and further changes may be required in the future, BANG endorses the present proposals as a first crucial step in securing real benefits to the neighbourhood. BANG's considered view, formed independently of the Council, is that these proposals should go forward to implementation rather than being allowed to get bogged down in further rounds of discussion and debate. That could lose us this opportunity for worthwhile easing of severe neighbourhood problems. Positive response to the consultation could yield implementation on the ground as soon as summer 2002.
(Click on Traffic Problems (on right hand side of screen for detailed information.)

September 2001

University Residential Properties Project: The University of Sheffield Newsletter of 3 August 2001 reported in the following terms on the residence decision. "A preferred bidder has now been selected for a Public Private Partnership Project to operate the University1s residential properties over a 30 year period". It then went on to state that approval for Bristol based United Group plc to enter the final phase of negotiations to operate university residences was given by the University Council, after a detailed evaluation of separate bids. The chosen company specialises in the provision of student accommodation, and already operates in other UK universities as well as in the city of Sheffield, including the Devonshire Quarter. A key objective identified by the Council in selecting a preferred bidder was the improvement of its properties for the benefit of students, including increasing the proportion of the popular en suite and self catered units, improving IT access and offering comprehensive pastoral care across the residences. It is anticipated that agreement will be reached between the University and the preferred bidder by the end of the calendar year 2001. However, during the transitional period current services to the residents will continue until the end of the academic year 2001/02. The above arrangement will apply to the six halls of residence (providing accommodation for 2,870 students), and a wide range of self-catering flats and houses, which together provide accommodation for 2,180 students.

Sept. 2001 (cont.)

Westbourne Senior School, formerly Ashdell House. In less than a year, Ashdell House, formerly used as an extension to Stephenson Hall of Residence, has been completely transformed and by 4 September will be in use as the Senior School of Westbourne School, catering for a maximum of 90 pupils. Both internally and externally the building and grounds have been completely 'rediscovered' and opened up, revealing what was a hidden jewel in the Broomhill area. Inside the main building the formerly un-used basement has been developed to provide cloakrooms, toilets and common rooms. The ground floor now provides teaching accommodation, as does the first floor. By judicious removal of some internal walls spacious and well lit rooms have been provided. The separate Coach House provides, on the ground floor, a small Assembly room (useful, perhaps, for BANG AGMs!) and upstairs a large and attractive room has been created, now showing the original beams. Around the two buildings the whole area has been transformed, with a vehicular entrance from Ashdell Road and pedestrian access both from Ashdell Road and the 'link' road, which has been narrowed and fitted with 'speed bumps'. On Thursday 11 October the Headmaster, Colin Wilmshurst, will be holding Open House between 7 and 8 pm for local residents wishing to see the new Senior School. A warm welcome with wine awaits you!

Dec. 2000

Ashdell House has been acquired and developed by Westbourne School. The purchase of this property from the University of Sheffield by the school did not, however, include the sunken gardens behind the house or the adjacent tennis courts. It now seems unlikely that the University will be selling off any more of its green spaces round halls of residence for development. On the matter of halls of residence and other University properties in general, a recent University Newsletter reported that the University has been looking into the possibility of developing a Public Private Partnership to take responsibility for running residential properties. As required by European law, notification of this Residential Properties Project has been published in The Official Journal of the European Community. The next steps will involve a lengthy process of bidding and consultation. The "most appropriate package" will not reach the University Council for final decision on whether to proceed until the summer of 2001.

As always BANG is concerned about various other planning applications which affect the conservation area and has been in touch with the Leeds group HEAL (HEADINGLEY AGAINST LANDLORDISM), which has focused on the issue of HMOs (Houses in Multiple Occupancy) and the undesirability of areas developing into student ghettos. Recently in Broomhill there have been applications for alterations to buildings for use as student accommodation in Elmore Road and Marlborough Road and one for 12 flats and car parking on land adjoining 16 Manchester Road.

August 2000

Ashdell House - Westbourne School now owns Ashdell House and the adjoining sunken garden. It is aimed to use the site for a maximum of 90 girls and boys, aged 13 to 16. The house is being re-roofed; the next stage will be to transform the interior of the building, including turning the Coach House into and Art and Design Centre. There will be a new road in from Ashdell Road, providing a drop-off and pick-up zone for parents. Ar arboreal expert is being consulted for advice on how to restore the sunken garden to at least some of its former glory.

June 2000

One matter causing concern is the damage being done to housing stock in areas such as Broomhill by the rapid growth in the number of houses in multiple occupation (HMOs). The effect of high concentrations of HMOs on community relations and services has been noted and in cities like Leeds legislation is being sought empowering local authority planning departments to restrict the conversion of existing family homes into HMOs.

Dec. 1999

Broomhill Committee Meeting 2 December 1999

The committee was reminded that an application had been submitted some two years ago for a tea room on the site of the toilets opposite the Royal Hallamshire Hospital. The significance of the work at present on this site would be further investigated.

University Sale of Land: No further developments, but the new Head of Planning had invited local residents to examine the Crosby Homes revised plans and submit their comments anew.

Broomhill Forum: It was agreed at the last meeting of the Broomhill Forum that it was more appropriate for the Forum to send delegates to the Sharrow/Nether Edge/Broomhill Area Panel than for Bang to be represented.

Nightclubs /Late Night Buses: various meetings had been held with all concerned - club managers, wardens of halls of residence, et al. This matter was also raised at the Broomhill Forum.

Environmental Sub-Group: there had been discussions with the City's Traffic and Planning Officer for Broomhill. Here again Broomhill and Broomhall problems would be linked at a forthcoming meeting.

Local litter: the local litter situation was discussed. A member had conducted a personal survey and apart from giant cleansing machines being deployed around midnight and after (this has now been discontinued) - the litter situation had greatly improved, although the promised new bins are still awaited. BANG would write to Cleansing Services to offer congratulations.

Dec 1997

Broomhill has gained yet another barber/hairdresser - City Gents, making three in the stretch of Fulwood Road between Nile Street and Glossop Road. There are currently seven empty shops in Broomhill, two of them former Building Society premises and it is difficult to know what type of shop would be viable.

The conversion of the block of four shops on the South side of Whitham Road to houses has certainly enhanced that stretch of road.

Sept. 1997

Broomhill Methodist Church and Flats
Work on these buildings has progressed rapidly since the Foundation Stone was laid on 17 May. Work is on schedule for the opening of the church in February next year. We are looking forward to having a new landmark on a site which many thought would become a nature reserve by default! Broomhill is in need of the extra meeting rooms that will become available. There will be parking spaces for 15 cars at the rear of the church.

May 1997

Our shopping centre continues to change and it seems that every shop that becomes vacant is the subject to a planning application for a fast food outlet. We lost the only remaining butcher in Broomhill with the closure of Bowyers last summer - the shop had been a butcher ever since it was built in 1840! Permission has just been granted for it to become a cafe, hot-food takeaway and a deli. We are fortunate in still having some "real" shops and it is very important that we support these, including the non-food shops, on a regular basis if we are to retain a viable shopping centre.

The issue which is uppermost with the Committee at present is the problem of traffic and parking. We have very few residents' parking schemes and very little acknowledgement by the Council departments concerned that there is a problem. We are hoping to set up a working party to collect information and ideas, propose solutions and set about getting them implemented. Your input to this project over the coming year will be very welcome.

Feb 1997

We all need to support what local shops we have left if they are to survive. The closure of each shop has a knock-on effect in making Broomhill a less desirable shopping centre. If we want to have any food shops left then we must patronise them on a regular basis or, as has been the case with our butcher, they will not be there. We are fortunate in still having two "proper" bakers, two greengrocers, a fishmonger and an excellent "deli", but for how much longer if we don't use them. Even the non-food shops need our support. The closure of the Broomhill TSB branch has been another blow to the shop keepers.

Aug 1995

We have once again had a "summer of discontent" with the University applying yet again for the erection of an annex to Tapton Hall of Residence and several other applications that affect the character of Broomhill.

Weston Park
A Public Meeting was held on 15 August to discuss the various options concerning this park. The "favoured" proposal is a partnership with Sheffield University under which they would take over the running of the Park for the next 50 years. They will not be given a lease and the Park will be managed by a committee with equal representation from the Council and University and some representation from the local community groups. The Council would have the final say on any landscaping and building work. There is a reasonable probability that the Park will be listed by English Heritage. The University have withdrawn any plans to build a car park under the existing tennis courts and also their proposal to close part of Northumberland Road. Not surprisingly there was considerable suspicion about the University's motives. The conservatories and bandstand will not be part of this agreement and will be open to proposals by developers and others, in order to generate income.

Note: A few months later this idea was dropped by the University as it proved unpopular with local people

May 1995

The most significant event of the past year has been the application by Sheffield University to build additional accommodation for students in the ground of Crewe hall, Halifax Hall and Tapton Hall of Residence. After much Press publicity and a prolonged campaign by BANG, the University held an Open Forum in Earnshaw Hall on 31st August. This well attended meeting was useful in showing the University that residents cared deeply about Broomhill and were concerned that the increasing imbalance in student numbers (over 6,000 students to some 2,800 "permanent" residents) was eroding the quality of life, both for the residents and for the students. It was stressed that we are not against students and that we in fact welcome them, although the minority that cause damage and create noise and litter are an increasing problem. When the planning applications were heard, the University was granted the application for a 114 study/bedroom annexe to Halifax Hall but refused permission for the Crewe Hall annexe for 21 flats and the Tapton Hall extension for 132 study/bedrooms.

Aug 1994

At the end of June the University of Sheffield applied for planning permission to build three new additions to their halls of residence (within the grounds of Crewe Hall, Halifax Hall and Tapton Hall). ...A petition asking the University of Sheffield to reconsider these plans for further expansion of the student population in Broomhill and the subsequent loss of green space and trees has been organised by BANG and has been signed by some 250 residents. Since many people are away on holiday some members may not been asked whether they wish to sign the petition, although they should have had a leaflet about the Open Forum. If you wish to sign the petition then please phone the Hon. Secretary as soon as possible, since the petition will be sent to the University by 10 September, with a copy to the Planning Department.

Nov. 1993

The building of the new Methodist church and the associated housing on Ashgate Road is waiting for the sale of the Carver Street premises. The sale to a brewery fell through when the application for a licence to sell drink was refused. Planning permission has been granted. Both the church and BANG are hoping that a new buyer will be found before too long.

The extension to the Hallamshire Hospital car park was finished on time and is now open. From observations when passing, it does not appear to be used by many people. There has been no noticeable difference in the number of cars parking on Beech Hill Road, Broomfield Road and other nearby roads.

Nov. 1992

Hospital Board developments
The long awaited expansion of the Royal Hallamshire Hospital's car park by 200 parking spaces is due to start in November. The building of 2 more decks on top of the existing car park will, however, mean the closing of the car park for up to a year, thus adding to the existing parking problems. We will try to monitor any resulting increase in parking on pavements or across people's drives and will need your help in letting us know of any such incidents.

Aug. 1992

After many years and seemingly many schemes, the Methodist church is hoping that the site on the corner of Fulwood Road and Ashgate Road in the middle of Broomhill will no longer be empty.

The church is working with the South Yorkshire Housing Association to build a new church and 11 flats on the site. The church building will front onto Fulwood road and the flats onto Ashgate Road. Car parking and vehicle access will be at the bottom of the site.

The church building is on two levels, providing a large hall on the lower floor, with ancillary rooms and several different sized meeting rooms on the upper floor, on the Fulwood Road level. Of particular importance to the church is that the premises should be as open and welcoming to the community as possible, particularly the Fulwood road frontage. It is currently progressing through the planning process.

Feb. 1992

After refusing an application for the erection of a house with integral garage and 3 flats, both within the curtilage of 24 Tapton House Road, permission has been granted for the erection of a dwelling house on land adjoining 32 Hallamgate Road and 24 Tapton House Road! Planning permission has also been granted for the use of 65 Westbourne Road as offices (it is at present flats). Permission was also granted for the demolition of Fairfield, 274 Fulwood Road, which was damaged in a mysterious fire whilst uninhabited, some two years ago. An application has been made for the erection of 2 houses and a bungalow on the site.

The conversion of the former tyre and car repair premises on the corner of Peel Street and Glossop Road into a Netto supermarket is proceeding rapidly. This site has until now always been associated with transport. It started life as a livery stable in about 1854 and became Collises cab yard some six years later. The cab yard lasted until about 1910 when the advent of the motor car changed its use into a garage which in some form or another it had remained until now.

Nov. 1991

Unitary Development Plan for Sheffield
28 members attended the meeting on 9 September in Westbourne School at which members from the Department of Land & Planning presented the new Development Plan and answered questions. The meeting was both constructive and helpful. BANG had prepared a statement of the views of the committee and this was given to those attending the meeting, as well as to the Planning Department. A further letter was also sent asking if Broomhill could be designated as a special housing area in view of the large number of students living in the area, at least 2,500.

A letter from the Planning Department has been received, thanking us for our comments and promising to let us know when the Consultative Report, which will show how the various comments have been dealt with, is published.

Stone Grove Maternity Unit
The new maternity unit will apparently be built at a cost of £20m. and is due to open in 1996. In the meantime, permission has been granted for the site to be used as a temporary car park.

May 1991

The Draft Unitary Development Plan
Copies of this plan for the future development of the City are available for consultation in Broomhill Library. The Committee have not yet had an opportunity to discuss this plan, which has only just been published. At first glance it would appear not to offer much change for Broomhill, nor much by was of additional safeguards. There is a proposal to make the Moor Oaks area one of Special Character, instead of including it in the Broomhill Conservation Area, as was requested. Tapton is also proposed as an Area of Special Character.

Nov. 1990

What's happened to Wesley
Ever since the Wesley Methodist Church, Fulwood Road, was pulled down, its site has been empty and has become an eyesore. What is the future of the site?

The Wesley Congregation have joined with the Carver Street congregation to form one church with the name Carver Street Wesley. It is the intention to build again on the Fulwood Road site and to establish an effective presence in Broomhill....It is envisaged that the building style will be of dual purpose so that it can be adapted for other community uses, as well as for worship.

Feb. 1990

The demolition of 8 Beech Hill Road, the completion of the office block in Peel Street and the work on the former Shelter shop, to link it with the Fox & Duck, are the most obvious developments.

 

 

Produced for the Broomhill Neighbourhood and Action Group by Map21Ltd *****Disclaimers - please read before using this website

The Banger

AGM records

Conservation Area

Development issues

Planning Applications

New housing

Pubs & Restaurants

Schools

Policing and Crime

Traffic problems

Litter

Events

FORUM

Local History

SEARCH

Return to top of Page

 

 

 

The Banger

AGM records

Conservation Area

Development issues

Planning Applications

New housing

Pubs & Restaurants

Schools

Policing and Crime

Traffic problems

Litter

Events

FORUM

Local History

SEARCH

Return to top of Page

 

 

The Banger

AGM records

Conservation Area

Development issues

Planning Applications

New housing

Pubs & Restaurants

Schools

Policing and Crime

Traffic problems

Litter

Events

FORUM

Local History

SEARCH

Return to top of Page

 

 

The Banger

AGM records

Conservation Area

Development issues

Planning Applications

New housing

Pubs & Restaurants

Schools

Policing and Crime

Traffic problems

Litter

Events

FORUM

Local History

SEARCH

Return to top of Page

 

 

The Banger

AGM records

Conservation Area

Development issues

Planning Applications

New housing

Pubs & Restaurants

Schools

Policing and Crime

Traffic problems

Litter

Events

FORUM

Local History

SEARCH

Return to top of Page